Close Menu
  • Home
  • News Update
  • Legal Updates
  • Free Legal Resources
  • Law News
  • More
    • Legal Articles & Commentaries
    • Recent Events
    • Promotions
    • About Us
    • S.C Report Online
    • S.C Report Printed Editions

Subscribe to receive Updates

Get the latest updates from us

What's Hot

UK introduces eVisas for Nigerian study, work visa applicants

July 9, 2025

Court Revokes Bail of Agribusiness Promoter, Ayodele Over Forged Medical Report

July 8, 2025

“Over 70 Vigilantes Killed in Bandits Ambush” — Plateau Communities Mourn Massive Loss in Anti-Crime Operation

July 8, 2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Lawbreed Blog
Visit our Website
  • Home
  • News Update

    Court Revokes Bail of Agribusiness Promoter, Ayodele Over Forged Medical Report

    July 8, 2025

    “Over 70 Vigilantes Killed in Bandits Ambush” — Plateau Communities Mourn Massive Loss in Anti-Crime Operation

    July 8, 2025

    “Allow Sufficient Time For Public Education, Infrastructure Setup” — Lagos Govt Announces Staggered Implementation Of Seven New Laws

    July 8, 2025

    Man bags life jail for robbery, kidnapping in Anambra

    July 5, 2025

    70-year-old man kills sister over family land in Jigawa

    July 5, 2025
  • Legal Updates

    How to Process a Change of Name at the Supreme Court : Updated Requirements

    May 8, 2025

    What residents should know and do about Wike’s land policy to protect properties

    April 15, 2025

    EXPLAINER: What constitution says about emergency rule, governor’s suspension

    March 19, 2025

    The Implications of ChatGPT for Legal Services and Society

    March 13, 2023

    Abia Assembly Passes Bill Allowing Female Children Share in Parent’s Inheritance

    November 25, 2022
  • Free Legal Resources

    US court orders FBI, DEA to release records on Tinubu’s investigation (See UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT MEMORANDUM OPINION)

    April 14, 2025

    Relief for Tinubu as U.S. judge denies Greenspan’s motion to fast-track confidential records disclosure by FBI, CIA, others

    October 24, 2023

    Nigeria wins $11bn P&ID case in UK court (Download Judgment)

    October 23, 2023

    Download: 12-hour marathon judgement delivered by the Presidential Election Petitions Court

    September 9, 2023

    (Download Judgment) It’s Unconstitutional, Unlawful For Minister To Deduct From Or Tamper With Financial Allocations To States — FHC Rules

    June 27, 2023
  • Law News

    “You Can’t Restrict Phones Without Legal Backing” — Court Bars EFCC From Seizing Visitors’ Devices At Office Gates

    July 8, 2025

    Thieves invade Ile-Ife court, steal two motorcycles

    July 1, 2025

    Court jails Wife, Mother-in-law, Rev. Father, Doctor for killing Lawyer

    July 1, 2025

    NJC Recommends 21 New Judges, Compulsorily Retires 10 Over Age Falsification [FULL LIST]

    June 27, 2025

    NJC Bars Justice Isaac J. Essien Of Industrial Court From Promotion For 3 Years Over ₦1bn Nasarawa Confiscation Order

    June 27, 2025
  • More
    • Legal Articles & Commentaries
    • Recent Events
    • Promotions
    • About Us
    • S.C Report Online
    • S.C Report Printed Editions
Lawbreed Blog
Home»Legal Articles & Commentaries»A Supreme Court Of Crises?
Legal Articles & Commentaries

A Supreme Court Of Crises?

Lawbreed LimitedBy Lawbreed LimitedOctober 30, 2022No Comments7 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Prof Chidi odinakalu
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email WhatsApp

By Chidi Anselm Odinkalu

In March 2017, columnist, Eric Teniola, began his article tracing the history of appointments to the Nigerian Supreme Court with the following lines: “[c]risis is not new to the Supreme Court in Nigeria. From inception, there has always been one crisis or the other in that court.”

That crisis of appointment has often been accompanied by a crisis of retention and mortality. When Stafford Foster Sutton retired as the last foreign Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), the government appointed an Egba prince, Adetokunbo Ademola, to succeed him as the on 1 April 1958. 14 months later, Olumuyiwa Jibowu, the first Nigerian on the then Federal Supreme Court, whose supercession by Ademola into the office of the CJN was facilitated by a suspiciously well-timed complaint about partisanship (which supposedly made him unfit for the office) died suddenly at 59. Since then, the Supreme Court has lived with triple crises of attrition, retention, and appointments.

20 years ago, Nigeria’s Supreme Court was in a very bad way. On 3 October 2002, Vanguard newspaper in Lagos led with the caption “Severe ailments ravage three Supreme Court Justices.” One of the Justices named in the story was Okay Godfrey Achike, whose judicial trajectory followed the academic route.

Obi Nwabueze, distinguished law professor and currently Nigeria’s senior-most Senior Advocate of Nigeria (SAN), no less, described Achike as “a first-rate academic and a fine teacher”. A distinguished academic career had taken Okay Achike through the faculties of law in the University of Nigeria, the Ahmadu Bello University, and Nnamdi Azikiwe University as well as the universities of Benin, Jos, and Lagos. In May 1986, Okay Achike became a judge of the High Court of Anambra State. 15 months later, in September 1987, Achike joined the Court of Appeal Bench.

In November 1998, Okay Achike became the 54th appointment to the Supreme Court bench. He was just under 66 years old and due to retire on 23 December 2002.

However, early in 2002, Justice Achike suffered a stroke forcing him ultimately to take early retirement from the Supreme Court at the age of 69 in August of the same year. He was too ill to even attend his own valedictory session the following month. One year later, in August 2003, he died.

The early retirement of Justice Okay Achike happened at the beginning of a bad season for Nigeria’s Supreme Court. Over the next three years, seven Justices left the Supreme Court. These were Justices Emmanuel Ayoola, Dennis Edozie, Anthony Iguh, Ekundayo Ogundare, Obioma Ogwuegbu, Chukwudinka Pats-Acholonu, and Samson Uwaifo.

Of these, Ekundayo Ogundare died in London in December 2003 from causes associated with colon cancer while Chukwudinka Pats-Acholonu died suddenly on 14 May 2006 of suspected cardio-vascular incident. Two others – Anthony Iguh and Obioma Ogwuegbu – survived hospitalisation for critical illness shortly before retirement. Indeed, Justice Ogwuegbu described his own survival as “a medical miracle.”

In comparison to the three serving Justices who died or were incapacitated over three years between 2003 and 2006, the Supreme Court suffered the death of three of its serving Justices over the 25 years from 1977 to 2002: Onuorah Dan Ibekwe in 1978 at the age of 58; Chukwunweike Idigbe in 1983 at the age of 59; and Augustine Nnamani at 67 in 1990. No Justice of the Supreme Court died in service in the 12 years to 2002 since the untimely passing of Augustine Nnamani.

Before the untimely death of Dan Ibekwe in 1977, the death of a serving Supreme Court Justice was almost unheard of. When he died on 1 June, 1959, Olumuyiwa Jibowu was a Justice of the then Federal Supreme Court, which was the equivalent of today’s Court of Appeal. The apex court for the country then was the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in London. John Idowu Conrad Taylor who died at 56 as the Chief Judge of Lagos in 1973, had served for three years as Justice of the Supreme Court from 1964 until he accepted appointment as the Chief Judge of Lagos State in 1967. Similarly, Buba Ardo, who died at 60 in 1991 as Chief Judge of Gongola State had stepped down from the Supreme Court into that role.

Two weeks after the death of Justice Pats-Acholonu, on 30 May 2006, this writer complained in an article about “the stresses our judges go through”, which argued that “mortality figures of the Supreme Court also tell a story about the working conditions of the Supreme Court.” Even worse, they tell a story about how those working conditions have evolved over time in the wrong direction. This matter of increasing attrition and mortality of Justices is also a reflection the management of work streams, occupational health, and wellbeing in the Supreme Court and, therefore, of a deterioration in deliberative assets that go into the court’s decision making.

16 years after that complaint in 2006 about the stresses that Nigerian judges have to endure, memories appear to have faded and the recent complaint by the current Chief Justice of Nigeria (CJN), Olukayode Ariwoola, about the triple crises of attrition, retention, and replacement at the Supreme Court appears to have inspired a reflex of handwringing, attended by a flurry of consciousness most of which look both undigested and hardly helpful.

It all began with the valedictory session on 15 September 2022 for Abdu Aboki, the most recent Justice to retire from the Supreme Court, where the CJN complained that his exit had “drastically depleted” the ranks of the Bench of the Court from the constitutional ceiling of 21 to 13. When they began the year, the CJN lamented, they were 17.

From the Body of Senior Advocates of Nigeria, BOSAN, the reaction was swift and immediate. On behalf of the Body, Onomigbo Okpoko, SAN, claimed that the complaint of the CJN was self-inflicted because of an appointment process that “appears to have been designed and operated to exclude good and competent lawyers from being appointed Justices of appellate courts.” Two years before this, the Independent Corrupt Practices Commission (ICPC) had reported that some senior lawyers were knee-deep in corrupting the judiciary with unmentionable sums. BOSAN did not seriously appear to have noticed this report.

The implicit suggestion by the BOSAN is that there is a sudden or quick fix to these crises in the Supreme Court which are nearly 65 years at least in the making. The idea that the country can appoint or replace its way out of these crises is unviable because such an approach does not respond in any way to the underlying pathologies that afflict the court. The issues are much more complex than that.

Three reasons make this is a good and necessary time to undertake a careful diagnosis of what afflicts the court. First, the legal profession, the public, and the politicians very much agree that the Supreme Court is living through a crisis but few have bothered to lay out clearly what the nature of the crisis is or how it came about in order for consensus to emerge as to how to fix it.

Second, all major issues in democratic and electoral politics in Nigeria sooner or later become the subject of litigation or judicial decision making. The Economist in 2008 famously described Nigeria as a democracy by court order. In the pecking order of the courts, the Supreme Court dictates what happens. Any crisis afflicting the Supreme Court in this system sooner or later occasions system-wide contagion.

Third, the country is in an election season which will be followed by a transition to a different government in another seven months. A competent diagnosis at this time should enable the country to provide fixes ahead of the election dispute resolution season or prepare to provide them immediately after the transition.

These rationales dictate, therefore, that we take a first principles look at the issues that afflict Nigeria’s Supreme Court. That is the only way to find out what can be done to address them.

A lawyer and a teacher, Odinkalu can be reached at chidi.odinkalu@tufts.edu

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Lawbreed Limited
  • Website
  • Facebook
  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Publishers of Judgments of The Supreme Court of Nigeria (S.C Report) - on the Authority of the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Related Posts

Good Night to a Humane and Consummate Jurist

June 21, 2025

Conflicting Decisions of Courts in Nigeria: Impact on Justice Delivery and Political Stability—Chief J.S. Okutepa, SAN.

May 23, 2025

The Lawyer’s Guide To Authenticating Electronic Evidence In Nigeria

May 13, 2025

Comments are closed.

www.lawbreed.blog
DARK HEARTS by Layi Babatunde, SAN – CLICK TO BUY
Top Posts

UK introduces eVisas for Nigerian study, work visa applicants

July 9, 2025536 Views

“You Can’t Restrict Phones Without Legal Backing” — Court Bars EFCC From Seizing Visitors’ Devices At Office Gates

July 8, 2025335 Views

Soyinka At UN: “Slave Trade Has Returned To Africa With One-Sided Ferocity”

March 26, 2025328 Views

Court Revokes Bail of Agribusiness Promoter, Ayodele Over Forged Medical Report

July 8, 2025302 Views
QUALITY BOOKS & LAW REPORTS BREEDS QUALITY PRACTICE
https://lawbreed.blog/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Law-Breed_x264.mp4
Don't Miss

UK introduces eVisas for Nigerian study, work visa applicants

General Update July 9, 2025

The British High Commission in Abuja on Wednesday announced a change to the United Kingdom’s…

Court Revokes Bail of Agribusiness Promoter, Ayodele Over Forged Medical Report

July 8, 2025

“Over 70 Vigilantes Killed in Bandits Ambush” — Plateau Communities Mourn Massive Loss in Anti-Crime Operation

July 8, 2025

“Allow Sufficient Time For Public Education, Infrastructure Setup” — Lagos Govt Announces Staggered Implementation Of Seven New Laws

July 8, 2025

US tightens visa rules for Nigerian students

July 8, 2025
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram

Subscribe to get Updates

Get the latest creative news delivered to your email. subscribe now

Supreme Court Report Online (My S.C Extra)
Our Picks

UK introduces eVisas for Nigerian study, work visa applicants

July 9, 2025

Court Revokes Bail of Agribusiness Promoter, Ayodele Over Forged Medical Report

July 8, 2025

“Over 70 Vigilantes Killed in Bandits Ambush” — Plateau Communities Mourn Massive Loss in Anti-Crime Operation

July 8, 2025

“Allow Sufficient Time For Public Education, Infrastructure Setup” — Lagos Govt Announces Staggered Implementation Of Seven New Laws

July 8, 2025
Don't Miss

UK introduces eVisas for Nigerian study, work visa applicants

General Update July 9, 2025

The British High Commission in Abuja on Wednesday announced a change to the United Kingdom’s…

Court Revokes Bail of Agribusiness Promoter, Ayodele Over Forged Medical Report

July 8, 2025

“Over 70 Vigilantes Killed in Bandits Ambush” — Plateau Communities Mourn Massive Loss in Anti-Crime Operation

July 8, 2025

“Allow Sufficient Time For Public Education, Infrastructure Setup” — Lagos Govt Announces Staggered Implementation Of Seven New Laws

July 8, 2025
About Us
About Us

Lawbreed Blog is owned by Lawbreed Limited, a full fledged Law publishing and marketing Private Limited Liability Company, incorporated under the Laws of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.

Email Us: mails@lawbreed.com
Contact: +2348077011730

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
Tags
Adeleke AMCON APC Bamise Bandits Bill BOSAN Bribe BRT Buhari BVAS CBN CJN Covid crime EFCC FEA FEATU featured FG FIRS Fraud INEC kano Labour Party Multichoice NBA New Naira Notes NICN NJC NUC o Old Naira Notes oransaye PEBEC Popular pwc SAN Shar'iah Supreme Court Tax Tinubu Trending Twitter VAT
Most Popular

UK introduces eVisas for Nigerian study, work visa applicants

July 9, 2025536 Views

“You Can’t Restrict Phones Without Legal Backing” — Court Bars EFCC From Seizing Visitors’ Devices At Office Gates

July 8, 2025335 Views

Soyinka At UN: “Slave Trade Has Returned To Africa With One-Sided Ferocity”

March 26, 2025328 Views

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.