Close Menu
  • Home
  • News Update
  • Legal Updates
  • Free Legal Resources
  • Law News
  • More
    • Legal Articles & Commentaries
    • Recent Events
    • Promotions
    • About Us
    • S.C Report Online
    • S.C Report Printed Editions

Subscribe to receive Updates

Get the latest updates from us

What's Hot

[FULL LIST]: FCT High Court Releases Official List of 66 Judges, their Designations and Postings

May 14, 2025

NBA Jos Branch Secures Release of Detained Lawyers, Police Officer Transferred

May 14, 2025

‘Even IGP Can’t Stop Us’: Jos Police Officers Allegedly Detain Lawyer for Representing Clients

May 14, 2025
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
Lawbreed Blog
Visit our Website
  • Home
  • News Update

    ‘Even IGP Can’t Stop Us’: Jos Police Officers Allegedly Detain Lawyer for Representing Clients

    May 14, 2025

    Court Orders Nigerian Govt. To Release Gas Flaring Data After HEDA Lawsuit

    May 13, 2025

    Fed Gov’t Bans Procurement Of Foreign Goods, Services Where Local Alternatives Exist

    May 6, 2025

    Meta threatens to cut off Facebook in Nigeria over huge fines

    May 3, 2025

    Bamise: BRT driver to die by hanging for murder of passenger

    May 2, 2025
  • Legal Updates

    How to Process a Change of Name at the Supreme Court : Updated Requirements

    May 8, 2025

    What residents should know and do about Wike’s land policy to protect properties

    April 15, 2025

    EXPLAINER: What constitution says about emergency rule, governor’s suspension

    March 19, 2025

    The Implications of ChatGPT for Legal Services and Society

    March 13, 2023

    Abia Assembly Passes Bill Allowing Female Children Share in Parent’s Inheritance

    November 25, 2022
  • Free Legal Resources

    US court orders FBI, DEA to release records on Tinubu’s investigation (See UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT MEMORANDUM OPINION)

    April 14, 2025

    Relief for Tinubu as U.S. judge denies Greenspan’s motion to fast-track confidential records disclosure by FBI, CIA, others

    October 24, 2023

    Nigeria wins $11bn P&ID case in UK court (Download Judgment)

    October 23, 2023

    Download: 12-hour marathon judgement delivered by the Presidential Election Petitions Court

    September 9, 2023

    (Download Judgment) It’s Unconstitutional, Unlawful For Minister To Deduct From Or Tamper With Financial Allocations To States — FHC Rules

    June 27, 2023
  • Law News

    Industrial Court nullifies Head of Service Guideline on Implementation of Teacher Retirement Age

    May 13, 2025

    Court Orders Refund of $20k bribe by EFCC operative back to lawful owner

    May 13, 2025

    Gombe CJ Grants Freedom to Over 80 Inmates in Bold Prison Decongestion Move

    May 8, 2025

    Lagos CJ Pushes for Enforcement of ECOWAS Court Decisions

    May 6, 2025

    Court jails two women for hawking naira in Lagos

    May 5, 2025
  • More
    • Legal Articles & Commentaries
    • Recent Events
    • Promotions
    • About Us
    • S.C Report Online
    • S.C Report Printed Editions
Lawbreed Blog
Home»Legal Articles & Commentaries»When the Making of a Tax is an Abuse of Rights By Prof. M.T. Abdulrazaq
Legal Articles & Commentaries

When the Making of a Tax is an Abuse of Rights By Prof. M.T. Abdulrazaq

Lawbreed LimitedBy Lawbreed LimitedJune 13, 2021Updated:July 15, 2021No Comments7 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Prof ABDULRAZAQ
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

One of the interesting developments of tax jurisprudence in the last decade is the importation of the concept of abuse of rights in setting the limits that a tax payer may go in legally planning his tax affairs in a way to limit his liability. The concept was explained in the English case of Barclays Mercantile Business Finance Ltd v Mawson (2005) STC 1 that a practice was abusive if the transactions concerned resulted in a tax advantage the grant of which would be contrary to the purpose of legal provisions.

The more interesting development is that of the Centros Case (1999)ECR 1-1459 where the argument was advanced that the concept may be used to protect the citizen against a State Institution or an exercise of the Law.

In our own context in Nigeria and where the National Assembly or the State Legislature introduces a tax, can a citizen or group of citizens affected by such action approach the courts to nullify the tax on the grounds that no institution of State should be allowed to be
unreasonable as to desire to the detriment of citizens, an improper imposition manifestly contrary to the objective of the law in conferring that particular right on the National Assembly or the State Legislature?

The starting point, is again, the Centros Case, a European Community Court Case, where the argument was advanced that the problem of abuse is resolved in the final analysis by defining the material content of the particular situation and thus, the scope of the right conferred. In
other words, it is claimed that to determine whether or not a right is actually being exercised inan abusive manner is simply to define the material scope of the right in question.

Three issues come to attention in this matter. The first, is to remember and keep in mind the judgement in Nicole v Ames (1899) 173 US 509 at 515 that “the power to tax is the one great power upon which the whole national fabric is based. It is not only the power to destroy,but it is also the power to keep alive ”.

The second, is to determine whether what the National or State Assembly seeks to impose is a tax. The celebrated definition of a tax is that enunciated in the case of Matthews v Chicory
Marketing Board (1938) 60 CLR 263 at 279 where it was held that “a tax is a compulsory exaction of money by a public authority for public purposes, enforceable by law,and is not a
payment for services rendered”. This definition was based on the definition enunciated by the Privy Council in Lower Mainland Dairy Products Sales Adjustment Committee v Crystal Dairy Ltd (1933) AC 168 at 175.

It follows therefore that fees for services rendered, the charge for the acquisition or use of property, penalties and arbitrary exactions are not tax.

The third issue, flowing from the second, is that taxation cannot be arbitrary, it must be capable of objective reference. Again, it is to the Centros Case we return, in this case, as guidance to the material scope of the right in question.

Therefore, if a right exists to impose a tax, then for the exercise of the right not to constitute an abuse of rights, a tax must in its material scope be imposed as a tax.

The only question, thus, to be answered is whether the imposition sought to be exacted by the National or State Assembly is a tax in its material scope?
The defining limits and guidance of the material scope of tax is provided by Frans Vanistendael and Victor Thuronyi in their work on the Legal Framework forTaxation and published in Tax Law
Design and Drafting, Volume 1, by the International Monetary Fund in 1996.
In general, the basic legal framework calls for taxation according to the rule of law.

The fundamentals of this framework are that a tax can be levied only if a statute lawfully enacted so provides, a tax must be applied impartially, and revenue raised by a tax can be used only for
lawful public purposes. The rule of law contemplates that these principles will be enforced by independent courts.

Vanistendael and Thuronyi further state that in addition to these very general principles, the power to make tax laws is subject to several types of legal limitations which include constitutional or other basic legal principles underlying an organized society, international
agreements, interpretation of the laws by the courts, the general framework of public law and political structure of the country as a centralized or a federal State.

In addition, to avoid the abuse of rights label, the National or State Assembly must maintain the principles of equality, the principle of fair play or public trust,the principle of proportionality
and ability to pay ,the principle of non-retroactivity, constitutional limitations, tax payers rights and international agreements.

Three abuse of rights examples provided will suffice for the present discussion.
In Belgium, the principle of equality was held to prohibit taxing companies providing professional services at the maximum rate. In Belgisch Staatsblad, No 89/94, it was held that the circumstance that a company was engaging in professional services was irrelevant as a criterion to determine the tax rate applicable under the corporate income tax.

Second, the principle that tax liability should be based on the taxpayer’s ability to pay is accepted in most countries as one of the bases of a socially just tax system. The principle of ability to pay is, for example, opposed to head or poll taxes, against which the British revolted
in 1990 under the Thatcher government.
Third, the Constitutional Court of Guatemala in Leyes y Reglamentos de la Tributaria 83,91-92, read a provision of the income tax law as taxing an item of income twice and struck it down as
violating a constitutional prohibition against double taxation.

Our legislators must respect the principle of legality on the basis of the prescription of “no taxation without representation” that was introduced in the Magna Carta in 1215. They must continually obtain our consent and act as a democratic guarantee against arbitrary taxation by
the government. They must have imprinted on their mind the words of James Otis that “taxation without representation is tyranny”.

The government at all times must remind itself of the words of Jean Baptiste Colbert, Minister of Finance under King Louis XIV of France (1619-1683) that ”the art of taxation consists in so plucking the goose as to get the most feathers with the least hissing” and learn from Mahabharata of Ancient India, that ”the ruler should act like a bee which collects honey without causing pain to the plant”.

With exploding deficits, a sluggish economy and a raging debate on how to improve our current financial situation, the nagging question for our democracy is “where exactly are we to draw the
bounds around the legislature’s right to tax the citizens”?

Abuse of rights is a civil law concept which can be traced back to Roman times as fraud on the law and its introduction into our democracy will be one of the greatest challenges to the
Nigerian Judiciary in the coming years.

 

*Professor M.T. Abdulrazaq is Professor of Taxation, Faculty of Law, Lagos State University, Provost, CITN Tax Academy and Tax Partner at Nolands Nigeria Professional Services

 

Download PDF version of this article below:

Tax
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
Lawbreed Limited
  • Website
  • Facebook
  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Publishers of Judgments of The Supreme Court of Nigeria (S.C Report) - on the Authority of the Supreme Court of Nigeria

Related Posts

The Lawyer’s Guide To Authenticating Electronic Evidence In Nigeria

May 13, 2025

“Supreme Court Ruling On Rivers Lawmakers Wrong” — Prof. Sagay SAN Criticizes Judgment That Allowed Defectors To Keep Seats

May 12, 2025

Justice Agim, Wike, And The University Of Calabar Convocation: A Response To Festus Akande, Supreme Court PR Director

March 26, 2025

Comments are closed.

www.lawbreed.blog
DARK HEARTS by Layi Babatunde, SAN – CLICK TO BUY
Top Posts

Soyinka At UN: “Slave Trade Has Returned To Africa With One-Sided Ferocity”

March 26, 2025327 Views

Pope Francis dies at 88 – Vatican

April 21, 2025256 Views

US Supreme Court stops Trump from deporting migrants

April 21, 2025222 Views

Reps Pass Bill Giving NBA Power To Remove Corrupt Judges Through No-Confidence Vote

March 26, 2025125 Views
QUALITY BOOKS & LAW REPORTS BREEDS QUALITY PRACTICE
https://lawbreed.blog/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Law-Breed_x264.mp4
Don't Miss

[FULL LIST]: FCT High Court Releases Official List of 66 Judges, their Designations and Postings

NBA May 14, 2025

The High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), Abuja, has released the comprehensive list…

NBA Jos Branch Secures Release of Detained Lawyers, Police Officer Transferred

May 14, 2025

‘Even IGP Can’t Stop Us’: Jos Police Officers Allegedly Detain Lawyer for Representing Clients

May 14, 2025

Industrial Court nullifies Head of Service Guideline on Implementation of Teacher Retirement Age

May 13, 2025

Court Orders Refund of $20k bribe by EFCC operative back to lawful owner

May 13, 2025
Stay In Touch
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • Instagram

Subscribe to get Updates

Get the latest creative news delivered to your email. subscribe now

Supreme Court Report Online (My S.C Extra)
Our Picks

[FULL LIST]: FCT High Court Releases Official List of 66 Judges, their Designations and Postings

May 14, 2025

NBA Jos Branch Secures Release of Detained Lawyers, Police Officer Transferred

May 14, 2025

‘Even IGP Can’t Stop Us’: Jos Police Officers Allegedly Detain Lawyer for Representing Clients

May 14, 2025

Industrial Court nullifies Head of Service Guideline on Implementation of Teacher Retirement Age

May 13, 2025
Don't Miss

[FULL LIST]: FCT High Court Releases Official List of 66 Judges, their Designations and Postings

NBA May 14, 2025

The High Court of the Federal Capital Territory (FCT), Abuja, has released the comprehensive list…

NBA Jos Branch Secures Release of Detained Lawyers, Police Officer Transferred

May 14, 2025

‘Even IGP Can’t Stop Us’: Jos Police Officers Allegedly Detain Lawyer for Representing Clients

May 14, 2025

Industrial Court nullifies Head of Service Guideline on Implementation of Teacher Retirement Age

May 13, 2025
About Us
About Us

Lawbreed Blog is owned by Lawbreed Limited, a full fledged Law publishing and marketing Private Limited Liability Company, incorporated under the Laws of the Federal Republic of Nigeria.

Email Us: mails@lawbreed.com
Contact: +2348077011730

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp
Tags
AMCON APC Bamise Bandits Bill BOSAN BRT Buhari BVAS CBN CJN Covid crime EFCC FEA feat FEATU feature featured FG FIRS Fraud INEC kano Labour Party metro Multichoice NBA New Naira Notes NICN NJC NUC o Obi Old Naira Notes oransaye PEBEC Popular pwc SAN Shar'iah Tax Trending Twitter VAT
Most Popular

Soyinka At UN: “Slave Trade Has Returned To Africa With One-Sided Ferocity”

March 26, 2025327 Views

Pope Francis dies at 88 – Vatican

April 21, 2025256 Views

US Supreme Court stops Trump from deporting migrants

April 21, 2025222 Views

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.